Professor J.N. Chubb was a distinguished philosopher and a mystic. His long career as professor of Philosophy at the Elphinstone College, Bombay, coincided with an intense churning in Indian philosophical thinking as a result of the debate in West between idealist philosophy and logical positivism. This was also the time when spiritual philosophies of India began to assimilate critically the trends of logical analysis, phenomenology, existentialism, pragmatism and other philosophies of will and of evolution. Professor Chubb's papers which are collected here by professor H.M. Joshi in this book reflect this process of churning and assimilation.
Professor Chubb passed away on 21st May 2001 after a long and dedicated career during which he inspired and guided hundreds of students, and influenced a number of philosophers in India and elsewhere. In his writings, one finds not only originally and self-conscious criticism of a high order, but also indications on future lines on which philosophy and empiricism meet in his philosophical thought, and East and West, too, greet each other in a sweep towards a possible synthesis.
In the series of books on contemporary Indian philosophers which are being brought out by the ICPR, this book will introduce to the readers a distinguished philosopher whose contributions have been extremely valuable and will continue to stimulate fresh lines of philosophical thought.
About the Author:
Harsiddh M. Joshi (1934-2004) graduated from University of Bombay in 1955 and obtained his postgraduate degree from the Gujarat University in 1958. He was for many years Professor and Head, Philosophy Department in M.S. University, Baroda. He was UGC Research Fellow in S.P. University, Rajkot, from 1996 to 1999. He authored several books including Nature of Mind, Knowledge, Value and other Essays, Contemporary and Traditional Ethics, Bradley and Sri Aurobindo, etc. He also wrote some philosophical books in Gujarati and some of them are prescribed as text books in several Universities. Professor Joshi was a member of Indian Council of Philosophical Research from 1998 to 2005.
ICPR records with sadness the demise of professor H.M. Joshi on 30 November 2004 and regrets that the book could not be brought out in time for him to see it in print.
Foreword | IX |
Preface | XV |
| |
1. Are There Sense-data? | 3 |
2. Hume on Personal Identity | 32 |
3. Empiricism, Rationalism and Metaphysics | 47 |
4. The Laws of Thought and Reality | 60 |
5. Kant's Doctrine of Synthetic A Prior Judgements | 75 |
6. Kierkegaard's Existentialism and Sri Aurobindo's Integral Philosophy | 82 |
7. Correspondence | 94 |
8. Need for Reconstruction in Philosophy | 101 |
9. The Problem of Truth | 119 |
10. Does Indian Philosophy Need Re-Orientation? | 130 |
11. Freedom | 156 |
12. Freedom and Truth | 164 |
| |
13. The Concept of Philosophy | 185 |
14. Metaphysics Note: Reality and Existence | 199 |
15. The Logic of Infinite | 216 |
16. The Potential To Be Realized | 232 |
17. A Life-Story That is Philosophy | 242 |
18. Sri Aurobindo - His Life and Teachings | 249 |
19. Indian Philosophy and Social Concern | 258 |
20. Sankara and Sri Aurobindo | 266 |
| |
21. Philosophical Arguments and Disagreement | 285 |
22. Vedanta - A Reformulation and Criticism | 335 |
23. Progress, Time and Eternity | 368 |
24. Some Objections Against the Ontological Argument Considered | 412 |
25. Can the Existence of God be Disproved? | 419 |
26. Metaphysical Reasoning and the Ontological Argument | 440 |
27. Above the Battle (an Essay in Metaphilosophy) | 465 |
28. Can the Existence of God Be Proved? | 485 |
29. Four Lessons of History | 598 |
30. The Anatomy of War | 603 |
| |
1. You | 613 |
2. Repose | 613 |
3. Strong Passions Rule Me Still | 614 |
4. My Country's History | 614 |
5. Unless | 615 |
6. I | 615 |
7. Joy | 616 |
8. Doubt | 617 |
9. Blind Souls | 617 |
10. To Krishnamurti | 618 |
11. Yearning | 619 |
12. The Fullness of Love | 619 |
13. India and Greece | 620 |
14. To J.S. | 621 |
15. The Cruel Star | 621 |
16. A Fairy Table | 622 |
17. Chains | 622 |
18. Delight | 623 |
19. Pride | 623 |
20. The Yogi | 624 |
21. Liberation | 625 |
22. Atman | 625 |
23. The Lost Art | 626 |
24. The Return | 626 |
25. Indian Womanhood | 627 |
26. Behold I Go Forth | 628 |
27. Sorrow | 628 |
28. To H | 629 |
29. But With the Whole Mind | 629 |
Index | 631 |
Professor J.N. Chubb was a distinguished philosopher and a mystic. His long career as professor of Philosophy at the Elphinstone College, Bombay, coincided with an intense churning in Indian philosophical thinking as a result of the debate in West between idealist philosophy and logical positivism. This was also the time when spiritual philosophies of India began to assimilate critically the trends of logical analysis, phenomenology, existentialism, pragmatism and other philosophies of will and of evolution. Professor Chubb's papers which are collected here by professor H.M. Joshi in this book reflect this process of churning and assimilation.
Professor Chubb passed away on 21st May 2001 after a long and dedicated career during which he inspired and guided hundreds of students, and influenced a number of philosophers in India and elsewhere. In his writings, one finds not only originally and self-conscious criticism of a high order, but also indications on future lines on which philosophy and empiricism meet in his philosophical thought, and East and West, too, greet each other in a sweep towards a possible synthesis.
In the series of books on contemporary Indian philosophers which are being brought out by the ICPR, this book will introduce to the readers a distinguished philosopher whose contributions have been extremely valuable and will continue to stimulate fresh lines of philosophical thought.
About the Author:
Harsiddh M. Joshi (1934-2004) graduated from University of Bombay in 1955 and obtained his postgraduate degree from the Gujarat University in 1958. He was for many years Professor and Head, Philosophy Department in M.S. University, Baroda. He was UGC Research Fellow in S.P. University, Rajkot, from 1996 to 1999. He authored several books including Nature of Mind, Knowledge, Value and other Essays, Contemporary and Traditional Ethics, Bradley and Sri Aurobindo, etc. He also wrote some philosophical books in Gujarati and some of them are prescribed as text books in several Universities. Professor Joshi was a member of Indian Council of Philosophical Research from 1998 to 2005.
ICPR records with sadness the demise of professor H.M. Joshi on 30 November 2004 and regrets that the book could not be brought out in time for him to see it in print.
Foreword | IX |
Preface | XV |
| |
1. Are There Sense-data? | 3 |
2. Hume on Personal Identity | 32 |
3. Empiricism, Rationalism and Metaphysics | 47 |
4. The Laws of Thought and Reality | 60 |
5. Kant's Doctrine of Synthetic A Prior Judgements | 75 |
6. Kierkegaard's Existentialism and Sri Aurobindo's Integral Philosophy | 82 |
7. Correspondence | 94 |
8. Need for Reconstruction in Philosophy | 101 |
9. The Problem of Truth | 119 |
10. Does Indian Philosophy Need Re-Orientation? | 130 |
11. Freedom | 156 |
12. Freedom and Truth | 164 |
| |
13. The Concept of Philosophy | 185 |
14. Metaphysics Note: Reality and Existence | 199 |
15. The Logic of Infinite | 216 |
16. The Potential To Be Realized | 232 |
17. A Life-Story That is Philosophy | 242 |
18. Sri Aurobindo - His Life and Teachings | 249 |
19. Indian Philosophy and Social Concern | 258 |
20. Sankara and Sri Aurobindo | 266 |
| |
21. Philosophical Arguments and Disagreement | 285 |
22. Vedanta - A Reformulation and Criticism | 335 |
23. Progress, Time and Eternity | 368 |
24. Some Objections Against the Ontological Argument Considered | 412 |
25. Can the Existence of God be Disproved? | 419 |
26. Metaphysical Reasoning and the Ontological Argument | 440 |
27. Above the Battle (an Essay in Metaphilosophy) | 465 |
28. Can the Existence of God Be Proved? | 485 |
29. Four Lessons of History | 598 |
30. The Anatomy of War | 603 |
| |
1. You | 613 |
2. Repose | 613 |
3. Strong Passions Rule Me Still | 614 |
4. My Country's History | 614 |
5. Unless | 615 |
6. I | 615 |
7. Joy | 616 |
8. Doubt | 617 |
9. Blind Souls | 617 |
10. To Krishnamurti | 618 |
11. Yearning | 619 |
12. The Fullness of Love | 619 |
13. India and Greece | 620 |
14. To J.S. | 621 |
15. The Cruel Star | 621 |
16. A Fairy Table | 622 |
17. Chains | 622 |
18. Delight | 623 |
19. Pride | 623 |
20. The Yogi | 624 |
21. Liberation | 625 |
22. Atman | 625 |
23. The Lost Art | 626 |
24. The Return | 626 |
25. Indian Womanhood | 627 |
26. Behold I Go Forth | 628 |
27. Sorrow | 628 |
28. To H | 629 |
29. But With the Whole Mind | 629 |
Index | 631 |