Warning: include(domaintitles/domaintitle_cdn.exoticindia.php3): failed to open stream: No such file or directory in /home/exotic/newexotic/header.php3 on line 772

Warning: include(): Failed opening 'domaintitles/domaintitle_cdn.exoticindia.php3' for inclusion (include_path='.:/usr/lib/php:/usr/local/lib/php') in /home/exotic/newexotic/header.php3 on line 772

Subscribe for Newsletters and Discounts
Be the first to receive our thoughtfully written
religious articles and product discounts.
Your interests (Optional)
This will help us make recommendations and send discounts and sale information at times.
By registering, you may receive account related information, our email newsletters and product updates, no more than twice a month. Please read our Privacy Policy for details.
.
By subscribing, you will receive our email newsletters and product updates, no more than twice a month. All emails will be sent by Exotic India using the email address [email protected].

Please read our Privacy Policy for details.
|6
Sign In  |  Sign up
Your Cart (0)
Best Deals
Share our website with your friends.
Email this page to a friend
Books > History > Some Blunders of Indian Historical Research
Subscribe to our newsletter and discounts
Some Blunders of Indian Historical Research
Pages from the book
Some Blunders of Indian Historical Research
Look Inside the Book
Description
About The Author

The author, P.N. Oak having made some far-reaching discoveries in history, is the founder president of the Institute for Rewriting World History. His latest finding is that in pre-Christian times Vedic culture and Sanskrit language held full sway throughout the world.

P. Oak was born in a Maharashtrian Brahmin family in which his father talked to him only in Sanskrit, mother only in English, relations in Marathi and town-folk in Hindi. That gave him fluency in these four languages from childhood.

After obtaining his B.A. degree from Agra University and completing M.A., LL. B, courses of the Bombay University, Oak worked for a year as tutor in English at the Fergusson College, Pune and later having joined the army was posted to Singapore at the age of 24.

There, after the British surrender, Oak was one of the organizers of the Indian National Army, a director and commentator at the Free India Radio, Saigon, and later a co-worker of Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose.

After the end of World War II, Oak hitch-hiked from Singapore to Calcutta across the border jungles of several countries.

From 1947 to 1974 his profession has been mainly journalism having worked on the editorial staffs of the Hindustan Times and the Statesman, as a class I officer in Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, Government of India, and as editor in the American Embassy's information service, all in New Delhi.

Around 1959, Oak developed a curious new insight into history which led him to some stunning discoveries as a result of his absorbing hobby of visiting historic sites. He then founded (June 14, 1964) the institute for Rewriting Indian History and wrote several books (listed elsewhere in this volume).

Oak's historical acumen led him to discover further that even world history has gone wrong. His discoveries have therefore, outgrown the name and scope of the Institute for Rewriting Indian History. Having discovered that from time immemorial up to the Mahabharat War, Vedic culture and Sanskrit pervaded the whole world.

Oak is keen to find a world Vedic Heritage University to educate the world in the primordial Vedic unity of all humanity. To that end he invites correspondence from all those willing to help.

 

Preface

Continuous alien rule in India for over a millennium has resulted in implanting in Indian histories numerous blundering nations as sacrosanct concepts. Those myths nurtured under government recognition and patronage for many centuries have now acquired a stamp of authority through sheer passage of time.

If by history we mean a factually and chronologically accurate account of a country's past current Indian histories deserve to be classed with Arabian Nights. Such history must be repudiated and rewritten. In this book I have indicated a few blunders of Indian historical research. The blunders listed herein are by no means the only ones. They are just a sampling of the vast scope for research that awaits scholars who are prepared to take a second look at Indian and world history and do some fresh thinking uninhibited by previous tutoring.

My earlier research publication titled TAJ MAHAL WAS A RAJPUT PALACE has already exposed a glaring and far- reaching misconception of Indian history.

Like a virus infection the blunders of Indian historical research have affected other spheres too. For instance students of architecture and civil engineering are taught to believe that mediaeval monuments in India and West Asia are products of Saracenic architecture while in fact it has been shown in the following pages that the Indo-Saracenic architecture theory is a myth. All mediaeval monuments are pre-Muslim Rajput monuments falsely credited to alien Muslim rulers. Likewise it was Indian architects and craftsmen who designed and built West Asian monuments since they were driven across Indian borders at sword-point to build such monuments in the native lands of the invaders.

Among the many weak links in the so-called Indo-Saracenic theory of architecture is the existence of Hindu patterns to the last detail in all mediaeval monuments. This is tried to be explained away as the result of the preference of the Hindu artists employed. There are many flaws in this arguments. Firstly chauvinistic Muslim accounts have never credited Hindu artists with designing their monuments. For instance in the case of the Taj Mahal they ascribe its design to some mysterious Essa Effendi.

Even if they credit any design to a Hindu, in those days of mediaeval cruelty and fanaticism they would never have tolerated any Hindu artist weaving 'infidel' designs into the pattern, of a Muslim mosque or tomb. So even this argument falls to the ground.

The other facetious assertion is that the master architect used to lay down the broad outline of the design, leaving it to- the individual workmen to fill in the details according to their individual whims and fancies. The hollowness of this argument becomes apparent on a little reflection.

Unless the entire contemplated design has been laid down at the very start it would be impossible to order the required' material of the kind and in the quantity desired.

If individual workmen were left to work out their own fancied designs they would all work to cross purposes and no longer remain amenable to the control of their supervisers since they would keep dodging and delaying, shirking and thwarting the project on the plea of lack of time or inspiration in fulfilling their part of the task. The argument that Hindu patterns adorn 'Muslim' monuments because Hindu workmen were allowed a free hand is thus palpably absurd examined from any angle.

Blundering assertions about the founding of Old Delhi is a typical instance of the absurdities that have formed part of current, distorted Indian history.

We are told that Old Delhi was founded by Mogul Emperor Shahjahan in the 17th Century. If that were true how is the epithet OLD justified? In that case it becomes the newest Delhi ever founded prior to British rule in India. As such it should rank with London and New York in age.

Taimurlang who raided Delhi in the Christmas of 1398 A.D. clearly mentions that he perpetrated his massacres in Old Delhi. He also adds that the Kafirs i.e. the 'infidel' Hindus collected in the Jama Masjid to counter-attack his troops. This proves that Old Delhi is in fact the oldest part of the sprawling ancient metropolis of Delhi.

Taimurlang's testimony also proves that Old Delhi's main temple was in Taimurlang's attack converted into a mosque. Had that not been so Hindus would never have rallied in that building. The fact that they gathered there as a matter of right proves that the building called Jama Masjid, erringly credited to Shahjahan, was a Hindu Temple when Taimurlang's troops stormed into Delhi.

There is yet another pointer to Old Delhi's antiquity.

In Delhi there is a monument called Purana Qila i.e. Old Fort. This is believed to date from pre-Muslim times and even from the Mahabharata era. If, therefore, Old Fort signifies the ancient-most fort how come that Old Delhi signifies a near- modern township! Such are the illogicalities which bedevil and vitiate current historical texts and underline the need for some re-thinking.

Besides being afflicted with distortions and anomalies Indian history has been badly maimed. Many of its important chapters are completely missing. Like the British empire within our own memory, in the remote past the Indian empire extended to such distant parts of the world as Japan in the East, Bali in the South, at least Arabia in the West and the Baltic in the north. Traces of this vast sway are delineated in some of the last chapters of this volume.

It is hoped that the present publication would prove helpful in highlighting a few major errors in Indian historical thinking and indicating the direction of research.

This book has been long out of print. This is its third edition. Hence it is being updated and some additions have been made here and there.

Readers have expressed great admiration over the contents of this book.

Professional historians have however maintained a stunned and studied silence because of the appalling thought that all they have studied and professed so far in history is basically wrong and must be unreservedly jettisoned. So they tend neither to admit their error nor correct it. Instead they pretend not to have heard of these discoveries or they try to pooh them.

 

Contents

 

  Preface 5
  What Prompted My Historic Quest 9
  Blunder No.  
1 Indian monuments Credited to Alien Muslims 17
2 Ignoble Akbar Believed Noble 81
3 Misplaced Faith in Mediaeval Chronicles 105
4 Myth of the Indo-Saracenic Theory of Architecture 126
5 Myth of the Moghul School of Painting 139
6 Myth of the Development of Music in Mediaeval Muslim Courts 141
7 Myth about the Moghul Garden Art 143
8 Mythical Golden Periods Under Alien Rule 146
  Key Principles for a Correct Appraisal of Indian Mediaeval History 147
9 Alexander's Defeat Claimed to be Great Victory over Porus 156
10 Adya Shankaracharya's Antiquity Under-Estimated by 1297 Years 169
11 Lord Buddha's Antiquity Underestimated by Over 1300 Years 184
12 Antiquity of Lords Rama and Krishna's Eras Grossly Underestimated 201
13 'Arya' an Ideal Misconstrued as a Race 212
14 Antiquity of the Vedas Grossly Underestimated 221
15 Origin of 'Allah'. as Hindu God and Kaba as Hindu Temple Forgotten 228
16 Indian Kshatriya Rule from Bali to the Baltic and Korea to Kaba Forgotten 242
17 Role of Sanskrit as Ancient World Language Forgotten 273
18 Hindu Origin of Prophet Mohammad Forgotten 281
  Monuments in Pictures 289

Sample Page


Some Blunders of Indian Historical Research

Item Code:
NAJ569
Cover:
Paperback
Edition:
2008
Publisher:
ISBN:
8188388262
Language:
English
Size:
8.5 inch X 5.5 inch
Pages:
324 (40 B/W Illustrations)
Other Details:
Weight of the Book: 360 gms
Price:
$30.00   Shipping Free
Look Inside the Book
Add to Wishlist
Send as e-card
Send as free online greeting card
Some Blunders of Indian Historical Research

Verify the characters on the left

From:
Edit     
You will be informed as and when your card is viewed. Please note that your card will be active in the system for 30 days.

Viewed 2767 times since 11th Dec, 2014
About The Author

The author, P.N. Oak having made some far-reaching discoveries in history, is the founder president of the Institute for Rewriting World History. His latest finding is that in pre-Christian times Vedic culture and Sanskrit language held full sway throughout the world.

P. Oak was born in a Maharashtrian Brahmin family in which his father talked to him only in Sanskrit, mother only in English, relations in Marathi and town-folk in Hindi. That gave him fluency in these four languages from childhood.

After obtaining his B.A. degree from Agra University and completing M.A., LL. B, courses of the Bombay University, Oak worked for a year as tutor in English at the Fergusson College, Pune and later having joined the army was posted to Singapore at the age of 24.

There, after the British surrender, Oak was one of the organizers of the Indian National Army, a director and commentator at the Free India Radio, Saigon, and later a co-worker of Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose.

After the end of World War II, Oak hitch-hiked from Singapore to Calcutta across the border jungles of several countries.

From 1947 to 1974 his profession has been mainly journalism having worked on the editorial staffs of the Hindustan Times and the Statesman, as a class I officer in Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, Government of India, and as editor in the American Embassy's information service, all in New Delhi.

Around 1959, Oak developed a curious new insight into history which led him to some stunning discoveries as a result of his absorbing hobby of visiting historic sites. He then founded (June 14, 1964) the institute for Rewriting Indian History and wrote several books (listed elsewhere in this volume).

Oak's historical acumen led him to discover further that even world history has gone wrong. His discoveries have therefore, outgrown the name and scope of the Institute for Rewriting Indian History. Having discovered that from time immemorial up to the Mahabharat War, Vedic culture and Sanskrit pervaded the whole world.

Oak is keen to find a world Vedic Heritage University to educate the world in the primordial Vedic unity of all humanity. To that end he invites correspondence from all those willing to help.

 

Preface

Continuous alien rule in India for over a millennium has resulted in implanting in Indian histories numerous blundering nations as sacrosanct concepts. Those myths nurtured under government recognition and patronage for many centuries have now acquired a stamp of authority through sheer passage of time.

If by history we mean a factually and chronologically accurate account of a country's past current Indian histories deserve to be classed with Arabian Nights. Such history must be repudiated and rewritten. In this book I have indicated a few blunders of Indian historical research. The blunders listed herein are by no means the only ones. They are just a sampling of the vast scope for research that awaits scholars who are prepared to take a second look at Indian and world history and do some fresh thinking uninhibited by previous tutoring.

My earlier research publication titled TAJ MAHAL WAS A RAJPUT PALACE has already exposed a glaring and far- reaching misconception of Indian history.

Like a virus infection the blunders of Indian historical research have affected other spheres too. For instance students of architecture and civil engineering are taught to believe that mediaeval monuments in India and West Asia are products of Saracenic architecture while in fact it has been shown in the following pages that the Indo-Saracenic architecture theory is a myth. All mediaeval monuments are pre-Muslim Rajput monuments falsely credited to alien Muslim rulers. Likewise it was Indian architects and craftsmen who designed and built West Asian monuments since they were driven across Indian borders at sword-point to build such monuments in the native lands of the invaders.

Among the many weak links in the so-called Indo-Saracenic theory of architecture is the existence of Hindu patterns to the last detail in all mediaeval monuments. This is tried to be explained away as the result of the preference of the Hindu artists employed. There are many flaws in this arguments. Firstly chauvinistic Muslim accounts have never credited Hindu artists with designing their monuments. For instance in the case of the Taj Mahal they ascribe its design to some mysterious Essa Effendi.

Even if they credit any design to a Hindu, in those days of mediaeval cruelty and fanaticism they would never have tolerated any Hindu artist weaving 'infidel' designs into the pattern, of a Muslim mosque or tomb. So even this argument falls to the ground.

The other facetious assertion is that the master architect used to lay down the broad outline of the design, leaving it to- the individual workmen to fill in the details according to their individual whims and fancies. The hollowness of this argument becomes apparent on a little reflection.

Unless the entire contemplated design has been laid down at the very start it would be impossible to order the required' material of the kind and in the quantity desired.

If individual workmen were left to work out their own fancied designs they would all work to cross purposes and no longer remain amenable to the control of their supervisers since they would keep dodging and delaying, shirking and thwarting the project on the plea of lack of time or inspiration in fulfilling their part of the task. The argument that Hindu patterns adorn 'Muslim' monuments because Hindu workmen were allowed a free hand is thus palpably absurd examined from any angle.

Blundering assertions about the founding of Old Delhi is a typical instance of the absurdities that have formed part of current, distorted Indian history.

We are told that Old Delhi was founded by Mogul Emperor Shahjahan in the 17th Century. If that were true how is the epithet OLD justified? In that case it becomes the newest Delhi ever founded prior to British rule in India. As such it should rank with London and New York in age.

Taimurlang who raided Delhi in the Christmas of 1398 A.D. clearly mentions that he perpetrated his massacres in Old Delhi. He also adds that the Kafirs i.e. the 'infidel' Hindus collected in the Jama Masjid to counter-attack his troops. This proves that Old Delhi is in fact the oldest part of the sprawling ancient metropolis of Delhi.

Taimurlang's testimony also proves that Old Delhi's main temple was in Taimurlang's attack converted into a mosque. Had that not been so Hindus would never have rallied in that building. The fact that they gathered there as a matter of right proves that the building called Jama Masjid, erringly credited to Shahjahan, was a Hindu Temple when Taimurlang's troops stormed into Delhi.

There is yet another pointer to Old Delhi's antiquity.

In Delhi there is a monument called Purana Qila i.e. Old Fort. This is believed to date from pre-Muslim times and even from the Mahabharata era. If, therefore, Old Fort signifies the ancient-most fort how come that Old Delhi signifies a near- modern township! Such are the illogicalities which bedevil and vitiate current historical texts and underline the need for some re-thinking.

Besides being afflicted with distortions and anomalies Indian history has been badly maimed. Many of its important chapters are completely missing. Like the British empire within our own memory, in the remote past the Indian empire extended to such distant parts of the world as Japan in the East, Bali in the South, at least Arabia in the West and the Baltic in the north. Traces of this vast sway are delineated in some of the last chapters of this volume.

It is hoped that the present publication would prove helpful in highlighting a few major errors in Indian historical thinking and indicating the direction of research.

This book has been long out of print. This is its third edition. Hence it is being updated and some additions have been made here and there.

Readers have expressed great admiration over the contents of this book.

Professional historians have however maintained a stunned and studied silence because of the appalling thought that all they have studied and professed so far in history is basically wrong and must be unreservedly jettisoned. So they tend neither to admit their error nor correct it. Instead they pretend not to have heard of these discoveries or they try to pooh them.

 

Contents

 

  Preface 5
  What Prompted My Historic Quest 9
  Blunder No.  
1 Indian monuments Credited to Alien Muslims 17
2 Ignoble Akbar Believed Noble 81
3 Misplaced Faith in Mediaeval Chronicles 105
4 Myth of the Indo-Saracenic Theory of Architecture 126
5 Myth of the Moghul School of Painting 139
6 Myth of the Development of Music in Mediaeval Muslim Courts 141
7 Myth about the Moghul Garden Art 143
8 Mythical Golden Periods Under Alien Rule 146
  Key Principles for a Correct Appraisal of Indian Mediaeval History 147
9 Alexander's Defeat Claimed to be Great Victory over Porus 156
10 Adya Shankaracharya's Antiquity Under-Estimated by 1297 Years 169
11 Lord Buddha's Antiquity Underestimated by Over 1300 Years 184
12 Antiquity of Lords Rama and Krishna's Eras Grossly Underestimated 201
13 'Arya' an Ideal Misconstrued as a Race 212
14 Antiquity of the Vedas Grossly Underestimated 221
15 Origin of 'Allah'. as Hindu God and Kaba as Hindu Temple Forgotten 228
16 Indian Kshatriya Rule from Bali to the Baltic and Korea to Kaba Forgotten 242
17 Role of Sanskrit as Ancient World Language Forgotten 273
18 Hindu Origin of Prophet Mohammad Forgotten 281
  Monuments in Pictures 289

Sample Page


Post a Comment
 
Post Review
Post a Query
For privacy concerns, please view our Privacy Policy
Based on your browsing history
Loading... Please wait

Items Related to Some Blunders of Indian Historical Research (History | Books)

Early Indian Historical Tradition and Archaeology
by G.P. Singh
Hardcover (Edition: 2004)
D. K. Printworld Pvt. Ltd.
Item Code: IDD091
$35.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Indian Food - A Historical Companion
by K.T. Achaya
Paperback (Edition: 1998)
Oxford University Press
Item Code: NAL232
$35.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Ancient India (New Research)
Item Code: NAG304
$26.50
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Medieval India 1 (Researches in The History of India 1200-1750)
by Irfan Habib
Paperback (Edition: 2013)
Oxford University Press
Item Code: NAF775
$22.50
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Ancient India: In Historical Outline
by D.N. Jha
Paperback (Edition: 2016)
Manohar Publications
Item Code: NAF397
$20.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Testimonials
I received the statue today, and it is beautiful! Worth the wait! Thank you so much, blessings, Kimberly.
Kimberly, USA
I received the Green Tara Thangka described below right on schedule. Thank you a million times for that. My teacher loved it and was extremely moved by it. Although I have seen a lot of Green Tara thangkas, and have looked at other Green Tara Thangkas you offer and found them all to be wonderful, the one I purchased is by far the most beautiful I have ever seen -- or at least it is the one that most speaks to me.
John, USA
Your website store is a really great place to find the most wonderful books and artifacts from beautiful India. I have been traveling to India over the last 4 years and spend 3 months there each time staying with two Bengali families that I have adopted and they have taken me in with love and generosity. I love India. Thanks for doing the business that you do. I am an artist and, well, I got through I think the first 6 pages of the book store on your site and ordered almost 500 dollars in books... I'm in trouble so I don't go there too often.. haha.. Hari Om and Hare Krishna and Jai.. Thanks a lot for doing what you do.. Great !
Steven, USA
Great Website! fast, easy and interesting!
Elaine, Australia
I have purchased from you before. Excellent service. Fast shipping. Great communication.
Pauline, Australia
Have greatly enjoyed the items on your site; very good selection! Thank you!
Kulwant, USA
I received my order yesterday. Thank you very much for the fast service and quality item. I’ll be ordering from you again very soon.
Brian, USA
ALMIGHTY GOD I BLESS EXOTIC INDIA AND ALL WHO WORK THERE!!!!!
Lord Grace, Switzerland
I have enjoyed the many sanskrit boks I purchased from you, especially the books by the honorable Prof. Pushpa Dixit.
K Sarma, USA
Namaste, You are doing a great service. Namah Shivay
Bikash, Denmark
Language:
Currency:
All rights reserved. Copyright 2019 © Exotic India