Warning: include(domaintitles/domaintitle_cdn.exoticindia.php3): failed to open stream: No such file or directory in /home/exotic/newexotic/header.php3 on line 921

Warning: include(): Failed opening 'domaintitles/domaintitle_cdn.exoticindia.php3' for inclusion (include_path='.:/usr/lib/php:/usr/local/lib/php') in /home/exotic/newexotic/header.php3 on line 921

Subscribe for Newsletters and Discounts
Be the first to receive our thoughtfully written
religious articles and product discounts.
Your interests (Optional)
This will help us make recommendations and send discounts and sale information at times.
By registering, you may receive account related information, our email newsletters and product updates, no more than twice a month. Please read our Privacy Policy for details.
.
By subscribing, you will receive our email newsletters and product updates, no more than twice a month. All emails will be sent by Exotic India using the email address [email protected].

Please read our Privacy Policy for details.
|6
Sign In  |  Sign up
Your Cart (0)
Best Deals
Share our website with your friends.
Email this page to a friend
Books > History > India in Greece or Truth in Mythology
Subscribe to our newsletter and discounts
India in Greece or Truth in Mythology
Pages from the book
India in Greece or Truth in Mythology
Look Inside the Book
Description
Preface

NOTHING but a thorough conviction of the importance of testing the stream of History at its very source, would have induced that process of investigation with whose partial results the reader is here presented.

A gigantic mass of absurdities now lies exposed, for a sifting examination. It remains for the patient sagacity of European scholarship, working upon both Occidental and Oriental materials, to re-build, I trust, upon no unstable foundation, that Temple of History which national vanity has destroyed, and whose ruins national Bud'hism has obscured.

A thorough persuasion that no nation, as a body of men, would or could, gratuitously, through a series of ages, invent a series of tales, in themselves fabulous, in their results historical,-determined me in the resolution to enter upon a process which should test the doctrine of invention, or non-invention, and thus gain some criterion for an impartial and a final decision. That problem is now solved. A plain, practical, and positive appeal to the very language of the first Hellenic settlers, will give a correct answer to the patient inquirer after truth, Those primitive colonists have been traced with a precision that nothing but the singular cohesion of the constituent parts of that ancient form of society called "a tribe," could have secured. This is a species of argument that will be duly appreciated by the contemplative mind.

The evidence thus gained, is evidence drawn from no partial source-it is evidence drawn forth from nations whose impress is of the highest antiquity.

Amid the ruins of empires, or the transient memory of the mightiest conquerors, Time has very generally respected both the form and the name of the grand features of nature. Cities and Polities may have been swept from the earth; Dynasties of unrivalled splendour may have passed away, leaving scanty memorials,-possibly none-to record their renown; but it is not so with the history ineffaceably written on the venerable forms of mountains, seas, and rivers. These compose a language so vast and so enduring, that compared with them, the Pyramids, must be considered as dwarfed toys of agglutinated sand which must crumble to atoms before the structure of this language shall be destroyed.

One of the most valuable points, in connection with the results here wrought out, is this geographical basis. It has interpreted correctly, and it will continue to interpret correctly, those singular tales, in early Greek history, which have generally passed current with the literary world, under the name of "Myths." They are now proved to be fables, just in proportion as we misunderstand them; truths, in proportion as they were once understood. Our ignorance it is which has made a myth of history; and our ignorance is an Hellenic inheritance, much of it the result of Hellenic vanity.

The Sanscrit scholar will find a few irregularities in that process which I have developed. They are such as belong to a form compounded of the old Pehlvi and the Sanscrit, the latter serving as the basis, and the former the inflective power. A superficial glance over this branch of my investigation, will convey some idea to the philologist of two interesting facts. First.-The primitive dialects, whence sprang the Greek of Homer. Secondly. The exact way in which the Greek consonantal and vocalic combinations were pronounced by Herodotean and Thucydidean Greeks.

The apparent irregularities of orthography occurring in connection with the same word, will be found to be more imaginary than real. It will be well for the reader to accustom himself to such variations of form, but not of power, nor of signification. He will thus consider Lakedaimon, Lacedamon; Cabul, Cabool, Kabul, Kabool; Tibet, Thibet; Cashmir, Cashmire, Casmir, Kashmire, Cashmere; Ladakh, Ladak, Ladac; Attock, Attac, Atac, Uttuck; Goclapes, Gooklopes, Guclopes, Cuclopes, Cyclopes; Panjab, Punjab, Punjaub, Panchab; Phenicia, Phoenicia, Phoenikia, Phainikia; as identical. And so with geographical nomenclature generally. When, however, such varieties appear in this work, they will, with few exceptions, be found to arise from the necessity of running parallel with the irregular mean- derings of the Hellenic or Oriental streams. A notable example of the singular variety of these forms, will be found under the name Budha.

It is evident that two classes of literature must now be studied in connection with ancient Greece. First,- The Mythology of Greece, showing what Greeks thought and wrote in connection with their divinities, and the immense mass of legend in juxtaposition with them. Secondly,- The History, which at present lies buried beneath this mythology; which, as forming the very earliest records of Hellas, must be studied like any other portion of established history.

Henceforward, let us not, succumbing to an easy indolence, deny on theoretical grounds the existence of those truths which Geography has restored to History.

 

Introduction

WERE an Englishman to sit down, purposing to write the history of his native country previous to the Nor- man conquest-to sketch the outlines of the Anglo- Saxon constitution, laws, and customs; were he to speak confidently of the old Saxon kings; their attendants, military and civil; to unfold the origin of their people, the structure of their language, and their primitive settlements; it would not be too much to expect that he should have some knowledge of the Saxon tongue.

And yet, what must be said of the confidence of the antiquarians of Greece, who, though themselves Hellenes, have, with a profound ignorance of the early language of Pelasgian Hellas, turned twilight into darkness, by absurd attempts to derive the words and customs of remote antiquity from the Greek language-a language at that period not in existence? But this vain-glorious confidence is not the only thing for which they are answerable. They have thereby unwittingly originated a gigantic system of absurdities and a tissue of tales, the opprobrium of history, and the torment of the inquiring mind. We feel that all this mass of error has a foundation in positive fact; we feel that agency, the most vital, the most energetic, the most constant, is at work; mighty actors come and go upon the scene, and mighty changes take place. And yet we are called upon by Theorisers to renounce the instincts of our nature; to class the siege of Troy, the Argonautic expedition, the history of Heracles, the history of Theseusnay, the whole busy, crowded scene of early Hellas, with the product of mythopoeic propensities, and secretions from the fancy. Alas! for this dream! I shall prove incontrovertibly, not only that such things were distorted facts, but I shall demonstrate that the Centaurs were not mythical - that the Athenian claim to the symbol of the Grasshopper was not mythical-that the Autochthons were not mythical-that the serpent Pytho was not mythical-that Cadmus and the dragon's teeth were not mythical-that Zeus was not mythical-that Apollo was not mythical-that the Pierian Muses were not mythical-that Cecrops was neither legendary nor mythical; but as historical as King Harold. And this I purpose to effect, not by any rationalising process, but by the very unpoetical evidences of latitude and longitude, which will certainly not be deemed of a legendary nature.

I would here repeat a remark made on another occasion on the historical basis of mythology. Perhaps within the whole compass of mythology there is no system altogether more plausible than the Grecian. Its coherence betrays art in arrangement, but weakness the main incidents. A basis, however, it undoubted possessed, which was neither of an inventive nor fictitious character. What that basis was, is certainly not be eliminated from either poet or logographer, or historian, independent of extraneous aids. Such aids are presented to the inquiring mind in those two most durable records of a nation,-its language and its monument These adjuncts, though of foreign origin, are, fortunately, available for the elucidation of Greek mythology. There is nothing more calculated to blunt the keenness of investigation than any theoretic maxim which lays down some general position to meet general difficulties. Here, acquiescence must be the rule, and research the exception. Nothing can be more tempting to indolence. To assume individual or national feeling as the exponent of fact, and fact too possibly foreign to that individual (nation, must be a perilous mode of rescuing from error re-establishing truth.

 

Contents

 

  Introduction 1
Chapter One The Evidences of Indian Colonisation 12
Chapter Two : The Sources of Hellenic History 24
Chapter Three :The Emigrants 36
Chapter Four: Sources of Greek Error 47
Chapter Five: Oriental Research 58
Chapter Six: The Hellenes 68
Chapter Seven : Attica 82
Chapter Eight : The Northern Tribes 110
Chapter Nine: The Himalayans 135
Chapter Ten: The Centaurs 152
Chapter Eleven : Dodona and The Hyperboreans 170
Chapter Twelve: The Cashmirians 181
Chapter Thirteen : The Heliadse 223
Chapter Fourteen: The Bud'ha Sivas 254
Chapter Fifteen: The Promised Land 294
Chapter Sixteen: Time, The Basis of Error and Truth 325
Chapter Seventeen : Hesiod's History of Greece 352
Chapter Eighteen : Phoenician Bud'hism 385
Chapter Ninteen : Apollo-The Bud'hism of Ladac and The Ladacai-men 401
Chapter Twenty The Attac-t'hans 454
Chapter Twenty One The Bud'hist Missionary 486
APPENDIX    
GEOGRAPHY INDEX OF AFGANISTAN   563
  GEOGRAPHICAL INDEX OF GREECE, WITH 568
  INTERPRETATION ANNEXED  

 

Sample Pages

India in Greece or Truth in Mythology

Item Code:
NAK840
Cover:
Paperback
Edition:
2015
ISBN:
9788129137944
Language:
English
Size:
7.0 inch X 4.5 inch
Pages:
586
Other Details:
Weight of the Book: 300 gms
Price:
$36.00   Shipping Free
Look Inside the Book
Be the first to rate this product
Add to Wishlist
Send as e-card
Send as free online greeting card
India in Greece or Truth in Mythology
From:
Edit     
You will be informed as and when your card is viewed. Please note that your card will be active in the system for 30 days.

Viewed 2880 times since 28th Nov, 2018
Preface

NOTHING but a thorough conviction of the importance of testing the stream of History at its very source, would have induced that process of investigation with whose partial results the reader is here presented.

A gigantic mass of absurdities now lies exposed, for a sifting examination. It remains for the patient sagacity of European scholarship, working upon both Occidental and Oriental materials, to re-build, I trust, upon no unstable foundation, that Temple of History which national vanity has destroyed, and whose ruins national Bud'hism has obscured.

A thorough persuasion that no nation, as a body of men, would or could, gratuitously, through a series of ages, invent a series of tales, in themselves fabulous, in their results historical,-determined me in the resolution to enter upon a process which should test the doctrine of invention, or non-invention, and thus gain some criterion for an impartial and a final decision. That problem is now solved. A plain, practical, and positive appeal to the very language of the first Hellenic settlers, will give a correct answer to the patient inquirer after truth, Those primitive colonists have been traced with a precision that nothing but the singular cohesion of the constituent parts of that ancient form of society called "a tribe," could have secured. This is a species of argument that will be duly appreciated by the contemplative mind.

The evidence thus gained, is evidence drawn from no partial source-it is evidence drawn forth from nations whose impress is of the highest antiquity.

Amid the ruins of empires, or the transient memory of the mightiest conquerors, Time has very generally respected both the form and the name of the grand features of nature. Cities and Polities may have been swept from the earth; Dynasties of unrivalled splendour may have passed away, leaving scanty memorials,-possibly none-to record their renown; but it is not so with the history ineffaceably written on the venerable forms of mountains, seas, and rivers. These compose a language so vast and so enduring, that compared with them, the Pyramids, must be considered as dwarfed toys of agglutinated sand which must crumble to atoms before the structure of this language shall be destroyed.

One of the most valuable points, in connection with the results here wrought out, is this geographical basis. It has interpreted correctly, and it will continue to interpret correctly, those singular tales, in early Greek history, which have generally passed current with the literary world, under the name of "Myths." They are now proved to be fables, just in proportion as we misunderstand them; truths, in proportion as they were once understood. Our ignorance it is which has made a myth of history; and our ignorance is an Hellenic inheritance, much of it the result of Hellenic vanity.

The Sanscrit scholar will find a few irregularities in that process which I have developed. They are such as belong to a form compounded of the old Pehlvi and the Sanscrit, the latter serving as the basis, and the former the inflective power. A superficial glance over this branch of my investigation, will convey some idea to the philologist of two interesting facts. First.-The primitive dialects, whence sprang the Greek of Homer. Secondly. The exact way in which the Greek consonantal and vocalic combinations were pronounced by Herodotean and Thucydidean Greeks.

The apparent irregularities of orthography occurring in connection with the same word, will be found to be more imaginary than real. It will be well for the reader to accustom himself to such variations of form, but not of power, nor of signification. He will thus consider Lakedaimon, Lacedamon; Cabul, Cabool, Kabul, Kabool; Tibet, Thibet; Cashmir, Cashmire, Casmir, Kashmire, Cashmere; Ladakh, Ladak, Ladac; Attock, Attac, Atac, Uttuck; Goclapes, Gooklopes, Guclopes, Cuclopes, Cyclopes; Panjab, Punjab, Punjaub, Panchab; Phenicia, Phoenicia, Phoenikia, Phainikia; as identical. And so with geographical nomenclature generally. When, however, such varieties appear in this work, they will, with few exceptions, be found to arise from the necessity of running parallel with the irregular mean- derings of the Hellenic or Oriental streams. A notable example of the singular variety of these forms, will be found under the name Budha.

It is evident that two classes of literature must now be studied in connection with ancient Greece. First,- The Mythology of Greece, showing what Greeks thought and wrote in connection with their divinities, and the immense mass of legend in juxtaposition with them. Secondly,- The History, which at present lies buried beneath this mythology; which, as forming the very earliest records of Hellas, must be studied like any other portion of established history.

Henceforward, let us not, succumbing to an easy indolence, deny on theoretical grounds the existence of those truths which Geography has restored to History.

 

Introduction

WERE an Englishman to sit down, purposing to write the history of his native country previous to the Nor- man conquest-to sketch the outlines of the Anglo- Saxon constitution, laws, and customs; were he to speak confidently of the old Saxon kings; their attendants, military and civil; to unfold the origin of their people, the structure of their language, and their primitive settlements; it would not be too much to expect that he should have some knowledge of the Saxon tongue.

And yet, what must be said of the confidence of the antiquarians of Greece, who, though themselves Hellenes, have, with a profound ignorance of the early language of Pelasgian Hellas, turned twilight into darkness, by absurd attempts to derive the words and customs of remote antiquity from the Greek language-a language at that period not in existence? But this vain-glorious confidence is not the only thing for which they are answerable. They have thereby unwittingly originated a gigantic system of absurdities and a tissue of tales, the opprobrium of history, and the torment of the inquiring mind. We feel that all this mass of error has a foundation in positive fact; we feel that agency, the most vital, the most energetic, the most constant, is at work; mighty actors come and go upon the scene, and mighty changes take place. And yet we are called upon by Theorisers to renounce the instincts of our nature; to class the siege of Troy, the Argonautic expedition, the history of Heracles, the history of Theseusnay, the whole busy, crowded scene of early Hellas, with the product of mythopoeic propensities, and secretions from the fancy. Alas! for this dream! I shall prove incontrovertibly, not only that such things were distorted facts, but I shall demonstrate that the Centaurs were not mythical - that the Athenian claim to the symbol of the Grasshopper was not mythical-that the Autochthons were not mythical-that the serpent Pytho was not mythical-that Cadmus and the dragon's teeth were not mythical-that Zeus was not mythical-that Apollo was not mythical-that the Pierian Muses were not mythical-that Cecrops was neither legendary nor mythical; but as historical as King Harold. And this I purpose to effect, not by any rationalising process, but by the very unpoetical evidences of latitude and longitude, which will certainly not be deemed of a legendary nature.

I would here repeat a remark made on another occasion on the historical basis of mythology. Perhaps within the whole compass of mythology there is no system altogether more plausible than the Grecian. Its coherence betrays art in arrangement, but weakness the main incidents. A basis, however, it undoubted possessed, which was neither of an inventive nor fictitious character. What that basis was, is certainly not be eliminated from either poet or logographer, or historian, independent of extraneous aids. Such aids are presented to the inquiring mind in those two most durable records of a nation,-its language and its monument These adjuncts, though of foreign origin, are, fortunately, available for the elucidation of Greek mythology. There is nothing more calculated to blunt the keenness of investigation than any theoretic maxim which lays down some general position to meet general difficulties. Here, acquiescence must be the rule, and research the exception. Nothing can be more tempting to indolence. To assume individual or national feeling as the exponent of fact, and fact too possibly foreign to that individual (nation, must be a perilous mode of rescuing from error re-establishing truth.

 

Contents

 

  Introduction 1
Chapter One The Evidences of Indian Colonisation 12
Chapter Two : The Sources of Hellenic History 24
Chapter Three :The Emigrants 36
Chapter Four: Sources of Greek Error 47
Chapter Five: Oriental Research 58
Chapter Six: The Hellenes 68
Chapter Seven : Attica 82
Chapter Eight : The Northern Tribes 110
Chapter Nine: The Himalayans 135
Chapter Ten: The Centaurs 152
Chapter Eleven : Dodona and The Hyperboreans 170
Chapter Twelve: The Cashmirians 181
Chapter Thirteen : The Heliadse 223
Chapter Fourteen: The Bud'ha Sivas 254
Chapter Fifteen: The Promised Land 294
Chapter Sixteen: Time, The Basis of Error and Truth 325
Chapter Seventeen : Hesiod's History of Greece 352
Chapter Eighteen : Phoenician Bud'hism 385
Chapter Ninteen : Apollo-The Bud'hism of Ladac and The Ladacai-men 401
Chapter Twenty The Attac-t'hans 454
Chapter Twenty One The Bud'hist Missionary 486
APPENDIX    
GEOGRAPHY INDEX OF AFGANISTAN   563
  GEOGRAPHICAL INDEX OF GREECE, WITH 568
  INTERPRETATION ANNEXED  

 

Sample Pages

Post a Comment
 
Post a Query
For privacy concerns, please view our Privacy Policy
Based on your browsing history
Loading... Please wait

Items Related to India in Greece or Truth in Mythology (History | Books)

History of Satyananda Yoga in Greece (Set of 2 Volumes)
Deal 20% Off
Item Code: NAN788
$62.00$49.60
You save: $12.40 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
The Growth of Civilizations in India & Iran
by Iran Habib
Paperback (Edition: 2014)
Tulika Books
Item Code: NAF912
$29.00
SOLD
Muslim Slave System in Medieval India
by K. S. Lal
Paperback (Edition: 2016)
Aditya Prakashan
Item Code: NAM818
$31.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
India, Central Asia and Russia (Three Millennia of Contacts)
Deal 20% Off
by D.N. Tripathi
Hardcover (Edition: 2013)
Aryan Books International
Item Code: NAF961
$90.00$72.00
You save: $18.00 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
India: Another Way of Life
Deal 20% Off
Item Code: IDD245
$43.00$34.40
You save: $8.60 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
The Wonder That Was India I
by S.A.A. Rizvi
Paperback (Edition: 2005)
Picador India
Item Code: NAC194
$43.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
A Cultural History of India
Item Code: IDF960
$31.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
India: A Cultural Decline or Revival?
Deal 20% Off
by Bharat Gupt
Hardcover (Edition: 2008)
D. K. Printworld Pvt. Ltd.
Item Code: NAD267
$31.00$24.80
You save: $6.20 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
The Illustrated Cultural History of India
Deal 20% Off
by A.L. Basham
Paperback (Edition: 2014)
Oxford University Press, New Delhi
Item Code: NAI143
$31.00$24.80
You save: $6.20 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Testimonials
Namaste! Thank you for your kind assistance! I would like to inform that your package arrived today and all is very well. I appreciate all your support and definitively will continue ordering form your company again in the near future!
Lizette, Puerto Rico
I just wanted to thank you again, mere dost, for shipping the Nataraj. We now have it in our home, thanks to you and Exotic India. We are most grateful. Bahut dhanyavad!
Drea and Kalinidi, Ireland
I am extremely very happy to see an Indian website providing arts, crafts and books from all over India and dispatching to all over the world ! Great work, keep it going. Looking forward to more and more purchase from you. Thank you for your service.
Vrunda
We have always enjoyed your products.
Elizabeth, USA
Thank you for the prompt delivery of the bowl, which I am very satisfied with.
Frans, the Netherlands
I have received my books and they are in perfect condition. You provide excellent service to your customers, DHL too, and I thank you for that. I recommended you to my friend who is the director of the Aurobindo bookstore.
Mr. Forget from Montreal
Thank you so much. Your service is amazing. 
Kiran, USA
I received the two books today from my order. The package was intact, and the books arrived in excellent condition. Thank you very much and hope you have a great day. Stay safe, stay healthy,
Smitha, USA
Over the years, I have purchased several statues, wooden, bronze and brass, from Exotic India. The artists have shown exquisite attention to details. These deities are truly awe-inspiring. I have been very pleased with the purchases.
Heramba, USA
The Green Tara that I ordered on 10/12 arrived today.  I am very pleased with it.
William USA
Language:
Currency:
All rights reserved. Copyright 2020 © Exotic India